Medicare Supplement Plan G New Jersey Pricing Spans $147.88 to $283 a Month as the Gap Widens With Age, Filed-Rate Review Finds
Cherry Hill, NJ – September 7, 2026 – Medicare Supplement Plan G in New Jersey is filed by 18 carriers at rates from $147.88 to $260.98 a month for a 65-year-old, a $113 spread for coverage that is legally the same policy everywhere it is sold, according to CSG Actuarial filings EasyKind Medicare reviewed as of July 12, 2026. The gap does not hold steady. By 67 it widens to $116. By 69 it reaches $129, with the most expensive filing climbing to $283.
The plan letter is standardized by federal law, so price is the only real variable. WoodmenLife’s New Jersey Plan G block covers just seven policyholders, and its loss ratio hit 157% in 2024 and 114% in 2025, meaning claims exceeded premiums both years. Three rate increases followed in under two years, 9% in 2024, 15% in 2025, and 9% in early 2026, leaving WoodmenLife ranked 15th of 18 New Jersey Plan G filers and priced 39% above the cheapest option.
Bankers Fidelity shows the other end: it ranks second of 18 at age 65 and becomes the cheapest Plan G filing by 70. Its only rate increase on record is 6.9%, filed February 2026, with a loss ratio of 45% as of 2025. Membership grew fivefold in a year, worth watching, but the math today favors the policyholder.
A New Jersey resident is not stuck with a plan drifting the wrong way. Since Plan G is standardized, a policyholder can move the same coverage to a different carrier at any time, though applications outside a protected window generally involve medical underwriting. New enrollees have the cleanest path: the state’s six-month Medigap open enrollment period, starting with Part B enrollment, guarantees acceptance regardless of health history. Four of the 18 carriers also file a household discount of 5% to 11.1%, easy to miss shopping one insurer at a time.
Full carrier-by-carrier tables, updated monthly, are published at medicareyourself.com/medicare-supplement/new-jersey/pricing-ages-65-69 and medicareyourself.com/medicare-supplement/new-jersey/rate-index. EasyKind Medicare reviews the spread with New Jersey residents by phone at no charge, 855-559-1700; broker compensation comes from carriers and does not change the filed rate a consumer pays.
About EasyKind Medicare
EasyKind Medicare is an independent Medicare insurance brokerage based in Cherry Hill, New Jersey, and licensed in 35 states. Led by broker Anthony Orner (NPN 20586791), the firm publishes filed-rate data for Medicare Supplement plans and helps consumers compare Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, and Part D prescription drug plans across carriers. Reach EasyKind Medicare at 855-559-1700 or medicareyourself.com.
Contact
Anthony Orner, EasyKind Medicare, 1309 Route 70 West, Cherry Hill, NJ 08002, 855-559-1700, medicareyourself.com
Media Contact
Company Name: easyKind Medicare
Contact Person: Anthony Orner
Email: Send Email
Phone: 855-559-1700
Address:1309 Route 70 West
City: Cherry Hill
State: NJ
Country: United States
Website: https://medicareyourself.com
